Exclusivity clauses, retail leases, South Africa, multiple food grocer tenants
Major food retail chain groups have historically insisted on exclusive trading rights. However, many developers who had conceded to exclusivity clauses in the 1980s and 1990s are reconsidering the implications of such clauses on their centres, and more specifically the potential effects of excluding a segment of the consumer market by virtue of tenant selection and consumer brand preferences. Legal inquiries ensued, including contract law and the rights of the tenant; common law and the potential effects of denying the consumer access to preferred brands; as well as potential anti-competitive practices by virtue of the exclusion of certain tenants from a shopping centre. The quantifiable impacts of dual or even multiple food grocer anchorage on shopping centre performance are investigated in the present study. Analyses based on comprehensive quantitative trading statistics of specific shopping centre size categories revealed identifiable and positive correlations between multiple food grocer anchorage, on the one hand, and aggregate shopping centre trading densities and foot counts, on the other hand. These findings suggest, first, that the average consumer supports more than one food grocer brand on a weekly basis, and therefore does draw benefit from a shopping centre with multiple food grocer options and prefers such offerings over single grocer centres. Secondly, the shopping centre anchored by a multiple food grocer offering has an enhanced power of attraction and risk mitigation attributes over its single grocer peers. The findings make a unique contribution to the debate about the relative merits of single grocery tenant in South African shopping centres as against the merits of having more than one food grocer anchor and provide shopping centre developers with a methodology for quantifying such effects.
Full Text : PDF
- Cloete CE. (2015)Shopping Centre Management in South Africa. Fifth Edition. South African Council of Shopping Centres: Sandton.
- DEMACON. (2014) Shopping Centre Database. Unpublished, DEMACON: Pretoria.
- DEMACON. (2015) Consumer Research Database. Unpublished, DEMACON: Pretoria.
- Du Toit H & CE Cloete. (2016) “Perceptions on the Impact of Dual and Multiple Food grocer Anchorage on the Performance of Shopping Centre in South Africa”.Department of Construction Economics, University of Pretoria.
- Gitman, LJ. (1998) Principles of Managerial Finance. Eighth Edition. Addison-Wesley: New York.
- Marsh, T. D. (2016).) A Fresh Look at Restrictive Use Covenants in Retail Leasing (with Sample Provisions). The Practical Real Estate Lawyer.
- NEF. (2005) Clone Town Britain, The survey results on the bland state of the nation. The New Economics Foundation: London.
- MSCI. (2014) South Africa Retail Trading Density Index, Q4 2014. MSCI South Africa: Cape Town.
- Perales RC. (2002) "Consumer Choice in Competitive Location Models" Department d'Econnomia i Empresa Tesi Doctoral: Universitat Pompeu Fabra.
- Raven, J., & Lunsford, R. (2015).) HEB's sustainable competitive advantage. Journal of Business Cases and Applications, 14, 1.
- Rode & Associates. (2014)Rode’s Retail Report 2014: 4. Rode Publications: Cape Town.
- Rosenbloom B. (1976) “The Trade Area Mix and Retailing Mix: A Retail Strategy Matrix”, Journal of Marketing, Volume 40, No 4, October 1976, pp. 58-66.
- Smidt, A.B. (2014)Exclusivity clauses in lease agreements post the Competition Commission intervention. Werksmans Advisory Services. Edited by Creamer Media reporter.
- South African Council of Shopping Centres (SACSC). (2002)Shopping Centre Directory. South African Council of Shopping Centres: Sandton.
- South African Council of Shopping Centres (SACSC).(2012)Shopping Centre Directory. South African Council of Shopping Centres: Sandton.
- South African Council of Shopping Centres (SACSC). (2014)Electronic Shopping Centre Database. South African Council of Shopping Centres: Sandton.
- Timmermans H. (1993) “Retail Environments and Spatial Shopping Behaviour”, Behaviour and Environment: Psychological and Geographical Approaches, 1993, pp. 342 – 377, Elsevier Science Publishers.
- Zidel D. (2001) Basic Business Calculations. Penguin Books: Johannesburg.
- Legal Proceedings
- Pick‘n Pay versus Pietersburg Development Company (trading as Savannah Mall), 2013/2014. Unpublished, private arbitration.
- Anastasi, K. (2013)[Correspondence with Mr Kiriakou Anastasi, Owner, Anaprop, regarding the importance of dual and multiple food grocer anchorage in the Anaprop shopping centre portfolio]Centurion, 4 February 2013.
- Flanagan, P. (2013)[Correspondence with Mr Patrick Flanagan, Director, Flanagan & Gerard, regarding the importance of dual and multiple food grocer anchorage in Middelburg Mall and Highveld Mall] eMalahleni, 25 January 2013.
- Gomes, G. (2014)[Correspondence with Mr Gilbert Gomes, Senior Property Development Manager, ShopriteCheckers Properties, regarding the food grocer retailer’s view on exclusivity clauses] Midrand, 13 March 2014.
- Jacobs, J. (2015)[Correspondence with Mr Johan Jacobs, Jacobs Trust, regarding the value of differentiated food grocer anchors in contiguous Neighbourhood Convenience centres] Kempton Park, 1 April 2015.
- Kriek, J. (2014)[Correspondence with Mr Johann Kriek, Director, Resilient Properties, regarding the importance of dual and multiple food grocer anchorage in the Resillient shopping centre portfolio] Pretoria, 29 August 2014.
- McCormick, J. (2014)[Correspondence with Mr Jason McCormick, Managing Director, McCormick Properties, regarding the importance of dual and multiple food grocer anchorage in the McCormick Properties shopping centre portfolio] Centurion, 22 May 2014.
- Muller, M. (2015) [Correspondence with Mr Marius Muller, Chief Executive Officer, Pareto Limited, regarding the importance of dual and multiple food grocer anchorage in the Pareto shopping centre portfolio] Pretoria, 31 August 2015.
- Visagie, J. (2014) [Correspondencewith Mr Johan Visagie, Managing Director, Twin City Development,regarding the importance of dual and multiple food grocer anchorage in the Twin City shopping centre portfolio] Pretoria, 7 April 2014.